The Problem
You're Getting Charged for Leads That Were Never Real.
Most businesses running LSA are paying for spam calls, wrong-service requests, and calls from outside their service area. Google charges you for those leads by default. And most businesses don't dispute them, either because they don't know how, or they don't have time to fight with Google's support system.
On top of that, LSA rankings aren't automatic. Your profile competes against every other business in your market. Without active management, reviews, responsiveness, profile completeness, you slide down the list while a competitor with fewer jobs but a better-managed profile takes your spot.